A simple balancing solution

Here's the algorithm in action. They just need to add this balancing after the current matchmaker finds 24 pilots for a match.

Initial player pool of 24 pilots once a match is found using the current matchmaker (randomly generated average match score of each pilot's currently chosen weight class, refresh to see new example):
Array
(
    [0] => 145
    [1] => 723
    [2] => 565
    [3] => 351
    [4] => 736
    [5] => 616
    [6] => 588
    [7] => 531
    [8] => 128
    [9] => 659
    [10] => 887
    [11] => 124
    [12] => 428
    [13] => 835
    [14] => 377
    [15] => 434
    [16] => 472
    [17] => 439
    [18] => 615
    [19] => 834
    [20] => 687
    [21] => 563
    [22] => 522
    [23] => 737
)

Worst possible team: 4514 total, 376 average
Best possible team: 8482 total, 707 average
Worst possible skill difference: 3968 total, 331 average (This is how some matches are now)
Balanced skill difference: 134 total, 11 average (Why do we not do this?)

Balanced team one: 6431 total, 536 average
Array
(
    [0] => 887
    [1] => 834
    [2] => 736
    [3] => 687
    [4] => 616
    [5] => 588
    [6] => 531
    [7] => 472
    [8] => 434
    [9] => 377
    [10] => 145
    [11] => 124
)
Balanced team two: 6565 total, 547 average
Array
(
    [0] => 835
    [1] => 737
    [2] => 723
    [3] => 659
    [4] => 615
    [5] => 565
    [6] => 563
    [7] => 522
    [8] => 439
    [9] => 428
    [10] => 351
    [11] => 128
)


Would you like to play in the worst case scenario (how it currently is sometimes)? Or would you like to play an actual balanced match from the example above?